You could have a Witches and Warlock party and call it a Bewitching Bash.
For invitations you could enclose a love spell or a miniature witches broom. Be sure to reference the coven meeting and the witching hour at hand.
You could have home-made brooms (just crooked sticks with rafia attached) outside the front door. You could make up your own witch hat topiaries. Just get some long thin reeds from your local craft store, soak them in hot water and twist them into a cone shape. Run a circle of them around the base of the cone and stick them on an urn. Then decorate with small pumpkins, black cats, etc You could even spray paint the whole thing black. Black cats everywhere (I spent a day running from Goodwill to Goodwill store to pick up stuffed black cats and black cat figures for next to nothing, plus the Halloween stores always have lots of black cats). You could have a bit obvious witches alter with a bell, salt, dagger, candles, incense burner, a bunch of runes, bowl of water, springs of herbs, maybe a frog or two, etc. And you need a big chalked pentagram on the floor in front. (Just a big piece of plywood would work so you don't ruin your carpet or floor. In fact pentagrams work great everywhere. You'd need a big witches spell book laid out on the altar (any big huge book will do with a fake couple of pages to look like spells. Don't forget the tons of small bottles with a wide variety of items in them and stick on tabs calling them ear of bat or toe of frog. Then get bunches of plant and weeds in small bouquets, tie them up with old string and hang them from the walls everywhere. I went to a store in Flagstaff, Arizona where they had all these wonderfully decorated witches hats. The local Home for the Mentally Disabled made them to raise some money. They were amazing! Just plan pointed black hat but then they were swatched in colorful Halloween ribbons, some with lights, some with figures in them or masks in them or whatever was at hand. They would look great scattered throughout the party site. If you have an overhead fan, tie small witches on brooms on the end of each fan blade and have the fan on low so the witches are flying overhead all night. A good centerpiece would be a round mirror painted with a red pentagram and a votive candle at the tip of each star point. There are all kinds of wonderful witch posters at sites such as AllPosters.com or Zazzle.com. Get some old cheap shoes, layer them with glue and cover them with red glitter. Then stuff in some striped socks and lay it up against the side of the house by the front door. Oops - you got that wicked witch!
For fun, have a seance or have a spell or ritual you identified in advance for everyone to participate in.
The food could all be served in various sized cauldrons. There are so many different witch foods you could offer. The witch finger cookies, witch hat shaped calzones, canoli coven hats, breadsticks formed to look with broomsticks, caprese salad where the tomatoes and cheese are cut with Halloween cookie cutters. etc. For drinks you could have the 'Sweet Spell Twister' or get Harry & David's Witches Brew Martini mix.
These ideas all came from my eBook Halloween Entertaining & Decor, available on
www.debrisdecollette.com. There are many hundreds of additional ideas there. Check it out!.
Colletteaz